30 newspaper hoaxes that fooled America

30 newspaper hoaxes that fooled America

Long before social media, sensational stories could race across the country through newspapers, magazines, wire services, and word of mouth. From moon creatures and escaped zoo animals to fake giants, mystery aircraft, and alien crashes, these stories show that America's appetite for unbelievable news is much older than the internet.


The Great Moon Hoax filled the Moon with life

The Great Moon Hoax filled the Moon with life
Unknown artist / Wikimedia Commons

In 1835, The Sun published a sensational series claiming that astronomer John Herschel had discovered life on the Moon. Readers were told about fantastic landscapes and strange creatures, including humanlike beings with wings, in one of the most famous newspaper hoaxes of the nineteenth century.


Edgar Allan Poe sent a balloon across the Atlantic

Edgar Allan Poe sent a balloon across the Atlantic
Edgar Allan Poe / The New York Sun

In 1844, The Sun published Edgar Allan Poe's account of an extraordinary transatlantic balloon crossing as if it were breaking news. The story was fiction, but its detailed descriptions gave readers enough apparent evidence to make the impossible journey sound believable.


P.T. Barnum introduced America to a fake mermaid

P.T. Barnum introduced America to a fake mermaid
The New York Herald / Wikimedia Commons

P.T. Barnum promoted the Feejee Mermaid as a genuine curiosity in 1842. The grotesque specimen was assembled from animal remains, but advertisements, newspaper attention, and Barnum's flair for publicity transformed it into a national sensation.


The Cardiff Giant rose from a New York farm

The Cardiff Giant rose from a New York farm
Bain News Service / Library of Congress

Workers digging a well in Cardiff, New York, uncovered what appeared to be a petrified giant in 1869. The figure had actually been created as a hoax, but crowds paid to see it and newspapers helped turn the buried statue into one of America's biggest nineteenth-century curiosities.


Spirit photographs put ghosts in the newspaper

Spirit photographs put ghosts in the newspaper
Harper's Weekly / Wikimedia Commons

Photographer William H. Mumler became famous for portraits that seemed to show ghostly figures standing behind his clients. His work attracted both believers and skeptics, and newspapers helped make the debate over his supposed spirit photography a national spectacle.


The Herald unleashed zoo animals on New York

The Herald unleashed zoo animals on New York
New York Herald

In 1874, the New York Herald reported that dangerous animals had escaped from the Central Park menagerie and were attacking people across Manhattan. Only near the end did the paper reveal that the alarming account was fabricated, after the story had already frightened readers.


A man-eating tree supposedly waited in Madagascar

A man-eating tree supposedly waited in Madagascar
J. W. Buel / Sea and Land

Stories of a monstrous tree that could trap and consume human victims circulated in American print during the late nineteenth century. Illustrations gave the invented plant a vivid appearance, helping transform a fabricated travel story into a surprisingly durable legend.


A forged letter threatened Garfield's campaign

A forged letter threatened Garfield's campaign
Historical document / Wikimedia Commons

During the 1880 presidential campaign, a forged letter appeared to show Republican candidate James Garfield supporting unrestricted Chinese immigration. The document became a political controversy before investigators concluded that Garfield's signature had been falsified.


Investors bought into an electric sugar miracle

Investors bought into an electric sugar miracle
Electric Sugar Refining Company

The Electric Sugar Refining Company claimed to possess a revolutionary secret process that could refine sugar cheaply with electricity. Investors poured money into the business before discovering that the supposedly advanced technology was largely a carefully staged fraud.


A newspaper invented the Indian Rope Trick

A newspaper invented the Indian Rope Trick
Otis Lithograph Co. / Library of Congress

An 1890 newspaper story described an astonishing Indian magic trick in which a rope rose into the air and a performer climbed it before disappearing. The account was fabricated, but the story spread so widely that the Indian Rope Trick became an enduring part of popular culture.


Denver reporters decided the Great Wall was doomed

Denver reporters decided the Great Wall was doomed
Historical newspaper illustration / Wikimedia Commons

In 1899, Denver reporters fabricated a story claiming that American businessmen were involved in plans to demolish part of the Great Wall of China. Other newspapers repeated versions of the tale, proving how easily a fictional report could gain authority simply by appearing in print.


Mystery airships filled American skies

Mystery airships filled American skies
Chicago Times-Herald / Wikimedia Commons

During the late 1890s, newspapers across the United States published reports of mysterious airships appearing overhead. Some witnesses may have seen ordinary objects or astronomical phenomena, while other stories were jokes or inventions that grew more elaborate as newspapers repeated them.


One airship story became an outright newspaper prank

One airship story became an outright newspaper prank
Waterloo Daily Courier

The great airship wave encouraged newspapers to publish increasingly extravagant claims. In Waterloo, Iowa, one supposed encounter became part of the era's mix of practical jokes, questionable testimony, and sensational reporting about mysterious aircraft.


A Texas newspaper reported an alien crash in 1897

A Texas newspaper reported an alien crash in 1897
S. E. Haydon / The Dallas Morning News

A report from Aurora, Texas, claimed that a mysterious airship crashed into a windmill and that the pilot's remains were buried locally. The story later became a cornerstone of UFO folklore, despite the lack of convincing evidence that the dramatic crash ever happened.


A photograph created an impossibly huge potato

A photograph created an impossibly huge potato
W. L. Thorndyke

A promotional photograph from Colorado made the Maggie Murphy potato look large enough to require a team of men to move it. The trick image escaped its original context and circulated as if it showed a genuine agricultural wonder.


The Solid Muldoon became another petrified giant

The Solid Muldoon became another petrified giant
James Thomas Thurlow

The Solid Muldoon was presented in Colorado as the petrified remains of an enormous prehistoric human. Like the Cardiff Giant before it, the body was manufactured, displayed to paying visitors, and promoted through the same culture of sensational newspaper curiosities.


Newspapers kept discovering ancient giants

Newspapers kept discovering ancient giants
Omaha World-Herald

Turn-of-the-century newspapers repeatedly printed stories about enormous skeletons and supposed races of ancient giants. Illustrations and comparison charts gave these claims an air of scientific authority even when the supporting evidence was weak, missing, or nonexistent.


Another giant skeleton reached the front page

Another giant skeleton reached the front page
Newark Advocate

Reports of oversized human skeletons were irresistible material for newspapers seeking unusual stories. Headlines could transform fragmentary archaeological claims into apparent proof that gigantic people once inhabited North America.


The Grand Canyon supposedly hid an Egyptian city

The Grand Canyon supposedly hid an Egyptian city
Phoenix Gazette

In 1909, an Arizona newspaper claimed that an explorer had discovered a vast cave filled with artifacts suggesting an ancient Egyptian connection inside the Grand Canyon. The article even linked the supposed expedition to the Smithsonian, which has no record of such a discovery.


A mysterious city appeared above Alaska

A mysterious city appeared above Alaska
Popular Science Monthly

Photographs and stories about a so-called Silent City of Alaska suggested that an enormous distant city could sometimes be seen floating on the horizon. The image was presented as evidence of an extraordinary mirage, but the story became tangled with accusations of photographic manipulation and exaggeration.


Wisconsin newspapers met the terrifying Hodag

Wisconsin newspapers met the terrifying Hodag
The Wide World Magazine

The Hodag began as a Wisconsin tall tale involving a bizarre horned monster supposedly captured near Rhinelander. Staged photographs and enthusiastic publicity helped the invented creature escape its prank origins and become a permanent piece of local folklore.


Piltdown Man gave science the wrong ancestor

Piltdown Man gave science the wrong ancestor
J. Arthur Thomson / The Outline of Science

Piltdown Man was presented as evidence of an ancient human ancestor and received enormous international press coverage. Decades later, researchers demonstrated that the specimen had been assembled from human and ape remains, exposing one of archaeology's most notorious frauds.


Fairy photographs convinced famous believers

Fairy photographs convinced famous believers
Arthur Conan Doyle / The Strand Magazine

Photographs taken by two girls in Cottingley, England, appeared to show tiny fairies dancing near them. Arthur Conan Doyle publicly defended the images, and reproductions spread internationally before the photographers eventually acknowledged how the pictures had been staged.


One photograph made Nessie look undeniable

One photograph made Nessie look undeniable
M. A. Wetherell / Wide World Photos

The famous 1934 image known as the Surgeon's Photograph seemed to show a long-necked creature rising from Loch Ness. Newspapers around the world reproduced it as possible evidence of the monster, but the photograph was later revealed to have been staged with a small model.


A fake relic rewrote California history

A fake relic rewrote California history
Historical artifact / Wikimedia Commons

Drake's Plate of Brass appeared to provide physical proof that English explorer Francis Drake had claimed California in the sixteenth century. Scholars initially accepted the object, but later testing showed that the celebrated historical artifact was a modern forgery.


The press became fascinated with a death ray

The press became fascinated with a death ray
Underwood & Underwood / Popular Radio

Inventor Harry Grindell-Matthews attracted enormous publicity with claims about a powerful beam that could disable engines and destroy targets at a distance. Newspapers and magazines helped turn the mysterious death ray into a public sensation even though its most dramatic capabilities were never convincingly demonstrated.


Newspapers exaggerated the War of the Worlds panic

Newspapers exaggerated the War of the Worlds panic
The Evening Journal, Washington, Iowa

Orson Welles' 1938 War of the Worlds broadcast became famous for supposedly sending America into mass panic. Some listeners were certainly confused or frightened, but later research has shown that newspapers greatly exaggerated the scale of the reaction while reporting on their new radio competitor.


A shaved monkey became a visitor from Mars

A shaved monkey became a visitor from Mars
Tim Farley / Georgia Bureau of Investigation display

In 1953, three Georgia men presented a dead creature as an extraterrestrial visitor after staging a supposed flying-saucer encounter. Investigators discovered that the unfortunate Martian was actually a monkey altered to make it look unfamiliar.


The fur-bearing trout refused to stay fictional

The fur-bearing trout refused to stay fictional
Samantha Marx / Wikimedia Commons

Stories claimed that trout living in exceptionally cold water had evolved thick coats of fur to survive. Taxidermy specimens and repeated retellings gave the absurd creature a physical presence, helping an obvious tall tale survive in American popular culture.


The Aztec saucer story promised alien technology

The Aztec saucer story promised alien technology
David Mathias / The Denver Post

Claims surrounding an alleged crashed flying saucer near Aztec, New Mexico, became part of the postwar UFO boom. Promoters tied the story to recovered bodies and extraordinary technology, but investigations connected key figures behind the tale to fraudulent schemes rather than extraterrestrial visitors.